eBiz Help
Searching for targeted web traffic?
Pay Only For the Traffic You Actually Receive.
Microsoft Webcast
Learn how your small business can capitalize on global trends.
FREE White Paper: Stop Random Acts of CRM
Learn more about delivering a seamless customer experience.

Free Software Archive:
Enterprise and Home Networking Downloads

WebProWorld IT Forum

From where can I get exam simulation?
I’m currently doing job as a technical support provider and want to pursue a variety of Internet related careers through I-Net+ certification.

SmarterMail Whitelisting
I've got a client who is using SmarterMail Professional Edition v.2.6.1921.27523 I've got domain admin access to the mail server, so I can control the spam filtering and content filtering for all emails within the domain.

Software Piracy Will Expand With IT Market
For every two dollars’ worth of software purchased legitimately, one dollar’s worth was obtained illegally, says a new study from Business Software Alliance.




Recent Articles

Microsoft Push Will Jam Blackberry
Microsoft announced plans to squeeze the juice out of Blackberry when Steve Ballmer presented Windows Mobile 5.0. The new OS provides a number of new features for the handheld market and promises to hit companies like Research In Motion (RIM) and Good Technologies below the keypad.

Sun Rises With StorageTek
Sun Microsystems is buying Storage Technology Corporation or StorageTek for $37 per share in cash, adding up to about $4.1 billion. The acquisition has been approved by the boards of both companies.

Who Do You Want To Be Today? - HP and Microsoft Planning Identity Systems Dominance
Dennis Miller once said that "Bill Gates is a monocle and a Persian cat away from being a bad guy in a James Bond movie." Last week, Hewlett-Packard announced that it, along with Gates' Microsoft, is getting set to make a push into yet another market currently dominated by small niche players and Unix-based software platforms -- identity management systems at the national level.

Make Sure Your Intranet Is Well Perceived By Staff
Many intranets are only now beginning to show their true potential. However, many staff, having had unsatisfactory previous experiences of the intranet, may need quite some convincing that the intranet is now genuinely useful.

Info Technology Departments May Lose Staff
A long-term choice for IT departments means either focusing on services or providing more business value.

Cisco Walks the FineGround
Cisco Systems announced that it will be taking over data center networking systems maker FineGround Networks, a privately-held company based in Campbell, California.

The Seven Things You Have To Say About Security
A provider of information risk management solutions offers its take on George Carlin's famed bit, but on the serious side.

The Machine Readable Web
The vast majority of the Web is intended for human readers. The goal has been to create an online experience for human beings. It is an open and ever growing body of information.

Intel’s Craig Barrett Stepping Down
Paul Otellini will become the chipmaker's first CEO who is not an engineer, while Mr. Barrett becomes company chairman.

Microsoft and Sun Partnership Starts To Show Results
Microsoft and Sun Microsystems spent a lot of time at each other's throats in legal battles, but last year the two companies formed a partnership which is now starting to show its results.


06.07.05


How To Make Your IT Project A Success

By Dr. Gerald M. Hoffman

For an IT project to be a success, it must meet three criteria:
1. it must be completed on time,

2. it must be completed within budget, and

3. it must provide the full functionality originally promised.

The IT profession has been conducting IT projects for over thirty years. Yet about 75% of all IT projects fail to meet one or more of these criteria. Why? The reasons IT projects fail are listed below, more or less in the order of frequency of occurrence:

1. Inadequate or inaccurate specifications

2. Changing specifications

3. Insufficient user support

4. Bad estimates of required resources

5. Technical failure

6. Bad management of the project


At first glance it seems that if in IT project fails, it is the fault of the IT department and the IT people. Without question this is true some of the time. Technical failure is clearly an IT failure most of the time. (Sometimes IT is forced to use questionable technology by the rational demands of the competitive environment, or by irrational demands by users to have the best and latest.) Bad project management is also an IT failure much of the time. The IT community is aware of these failings and is making substantial progress in correcting them.

But there is more here than meets the eye. IT cannot do it alone. Substantial participation by users is essential to the success of every IT project.

Let's look at the role of users in a typical IT project in terms of the specific tasks that need to be done in each phase of development.

· User requirements specification - Users should do most of the work, with guidance about costs and technical issues from IT.

· Functional design - Users should lead this effort, with some participation by IT.

· Technical design - IT should lead this phase, with some input from users, as technical considerations suggest or require change in functional design. · Coding - No user participation required.

· Testing - Users must design the test cases, provide the test data and analyze the test results. This is a larger effort than most people realize.

· Training and documentation - While IT must create the technical documentation, user documentation of system functionality is best done by users.

· Implementation - The users must work in parallel with IT to install the new business processes required by every new system, even as they train the ultimate users of the system.

There is almost no reliable data on how much user time is or should be involved in these activities, but we in the IT community know that the requirements are large. In an attempt to understand the issue, I have conducted over 100 informal surveys of IT professionals in the course of my teaching in the Northwestern University's Communications Systems Strategy and Management program and in various other professional programs and industry seminars.

The survey consists of just two questions. I set the stage this way: "Think about a typical IT application development project that is now under way or that you have recently completed, and answer these two questions. Express your answer as the ratio of user work days to IT work days."


Here are the questions and the range of answers I usually receive:

1. How much user time should the project have had, as a percentage of IT time? Answers typically range from 25% to 50%.

2. How much user time did the project actually get? Answers typically range from 0% ("They told me to do it, and then disappeared until it was done.") to 15%.

My analysis tells me that user work time in an application development project should be from 25% to 100% of IT time, depending on the nature of the project.

If this strikes you as too high, consider our collective experience with comprehensive ERP systems a few years ago. These systems were so large that they required dedicated task forces of users to support their development. In many cases there were more users on the task force than IT people. For the first time, companies were confronted with the magnitude of user support required for major application system development and deployment.

In no case has any CIO (of over 200 I have surveyed) ever said that any project received as much user time as it required. The gap is usually closed by IT people doing the users' work. This guarantees project failure: · To the extent that IT people specify user requirements and functional design, the new system and its associated business processes reflect IT's view about how the business should be run. This is a bad idea. · Users often change requirements during the project, as they begin to understand the ramifications of the new system, or as business needs change. · If the users do not take the lead in the testing, the wrong things will be tested using the wrong data - a guarantee of a difficult implementation and needless maintenance costs. · When IT people write user documentation it is often unintelligible to the users; when the users can understand it, it often does not tell them what they need to know.

The overall effect of this transfer of work from users to IT is to degrade performance with respect to all of the key criteria of success: · Projects are late because IT has not allocated people to do the work that users should be doing, delaying the IT work they should be doing. Changing requirements magnify the problem. · Projects are over budget for the same reasons. · System functionally is compromised because the IT people do not know as much about business needs and business processes as the users know.

What's a manager to do? · If you the CEO or COO, do not authorize any project unless the user commits in advance to providing 50% of the work days budgeted for IT participation. · If you are the CIO, refuse to start a project without the user's commitment to adequate user participation.

The biggest IT failure is failure to get the users do their jobs.

About the Author:
Dr. Gerald M. Hoffman is an Adjunct Professor, Northwestern University. He is also a member of the Board of Directors of Sinai Health System. Contact: Gerry@ghco.biz

© 2005 by Gerald M. Hoffman


About ITProNews
News and updates for the IT professional

ITProNews is brought to you by:

SecurityConfig.com NetworkingFiles.com
NetworkNewz.com WebProASP.com
PerlProNews.com SQLProNews.com
SysAdminNews DevWebPro.com
LinuxProNews.com WirelessProNews.com
CProgrammingTrends.com ITCertificationNews.com


-- ITProNews is an iEntry, Inc. publication --
iEntry, Inc. 2549 Richmond Rd. Lexington KY, 40509
2005 iEntry, Inc. All Rights Reserved Privacy Policy Legal

archives | advertising info | news headlines | free newsletters | comments/feedback | submit article


ITProNews News Archives About Us Feedback ITProNews Home Page About Article Archive News Downloads WebProWorld Forums Jayde iEntry Advertise Contact